arrow53 Comments
  1. Chloe Forbes-Kindlen
    Jan 03 - 3:30 am

    I really liked this article Neil! I have to say, I always find it a little strange when I receive endorsements from people I have just connected with and don’t really know so well. It kind of feels like cheating , don’t you think? I haven’t earned it so I always feel like it’s not right to have them but I now get your point. It’s mutually beneficial option that I will now take a little more seriously- thanks!

    • Neal Schaffer
      Jan 03 - 8:56 am

      Glad you enjoyed my perspective Chloe. It’s weird in that LinkedIn is a network that people take most seriously, but they now have a component in Endorsements that can be taken as lightly or as seriously as you want. I say try to leverage those that receive wisely and pay it forward by giving to those in your network in a smart and engaging way.

      • Ed Brophy (@IncomeTrue)
        Jan 13 - 11:46 am

        I agree with you Neil: “It’s weird in that LinkedIn is a network that people take most seriously, but they now have a component in Endorsements that can be taken as lightly or as seriously as you want.”

        It is weird. Many experts say that casualness on the part of Linkedin will cause casualties, while many other people say to lighten up and don’t develop such a tragic view of it.

        Either way, this is why comedians say, “comedy is tragedy revisited”:
        http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mGS2tKQhdhY

        I agree with Sir Ken of Ted Talks who says, “If you’re not prepared to be wrong you’ll never come up with anything original.”

        Professional networking to me is about inspiring the dignity of personhood on social platforms – not to profile humans as workaholics.

        Emotional and social intelligence is brought out in people when they think about and work harder on developing their people skills, rather than just tweaking and profiling their technical knowledge.

        The most important and the most highly paid form of intelligence in America today is social intelligence, the ability to get along well and network with other people. Social intelligence is also known as your people skills.

        Ed Brophy,
        Open Endorser’s Group

        • Neal Schaffer
          Jan 13 - 12:13 pm

          Very interesting perspective Ed – thanks for sharing.

  2. Great post, Neal! I don’t have a lot to do with LinkedIn, so when I started getting these “so and so has endorsed you” emails, I was all “what’s that about?” and then promptly forgot about it. Now, i have some ideas about what to do with them!

  3. James Wu
    Jan 03 - 10:57 am

    Nice post. I’ll add one employment law nuance. Supervisors and Managers should take a moment to think twice about endorsing subordinate employees and what might happen if that employee is subsequently terminated for poor performance, or the like. Will a LinkedIn endorsement undermine the Employer’s position that it terminated the employee for poor performance? Similar (and other) issues with an employee endorsing a boss.

    • Neal Schaffer
      Jan 03 - 11:03 am

      Thanks James! You bring up a great point: Many companies will not allow their employees to write Recommendations for other employees. I assume that Employment Law holds the same for Endorsements … perhaps this is a topic for a future blog post, James? ;-)

  4. David Rowan
    Jan 03 - 11:38 am

    Great article Neal, thanks for the insight

  5. Alex Zmushka (@azmushko)
    Jan 03 - 12:56 pm

    Finally, someone has cleared it out!!! Thank you Neal! Awesome post! off to sharing..

  6. Vicki S. Cannon
    Jan 03 - 1:58 pm

    I really appreciate the perspective here. I liked when we could add skills, but when the endorsements started it was hard to know what to do with them. In my training classes I have been talking about using them as an excuse to connect with others (either by thanking them for the endorsement or by endorsing the other person) as long as you could do it with legitimacy. I’ll be interested to see if this changes anything for people during the “search” process. Any thoughts there?

    • Neal Schaffer
      Jan 03 - 2:04 pm

      Thanks Vicki! I actually referred to that here:

      I’ve also intentionally left out the potential that some see of LinkedIn adding Skills and Endorsements to their search results. One should align social media activities with what is reality instead of what might become real. But, obviously, should this happen, Endorsements will have a much bigger meaning for the branding of professionals AND businesses.

      LinkedIn has had Skills for several months and never introduced it as a search filter. I don’t expect things to change for Endorsements. If you own their HR package which allows you to search using more filters, however, I could see them integrating those results to help recruiters better find suitable candidates. But this is mere conjecture, and I would never make a recommendation based on assumption.

      Hope the above makes sense!

  7. Vicki S. Cannon
    Jan 03 - 2:22 pm

    Makes sense to me. I don’t see them (skills or endorsements) as part of search either, but wonder if they are “weighted” in the search. Of course, we may never really know what goes into the algorithm. :)

    • Neal Schaffer
      Jan 03 - 2:28 pm

      Yup – LinkedIn Search uses an algoritm just like Google does…

      • Ed Brophy (@IncomeTrue)
        Jan 29 - 12:35 pm

        In view of what your article here stated first Neil, and what this Linkedin investor article below is also now revealing about algorithms, is that it’s better to start out working on improving the way LinkedIn Endorsements can work for you now, then it is to wait. Is that correct?

        “These pieces of data will inform some kind of algorithm eventually to create a score that LinkedIn can give you for that skill which is relative to everyone else’s score for that skill.”:

        http://seekingalpha.com/article/1140401-some-thoughts-on-linkedin-endorsements?source=google_news

        Everybody has to start out somewhere..Perhaps your new or just getting started and haven’t attracted many contacts yet. So the initial approach then I believe, is to begin applying the principles of “social proof” and create an unrivaled perception in the way you present your skills and personal branding – then learn from results as Linkedin and you evolve forward.

        Open Endorsers are Open Networkers – only they have more skills.

        Join the Open Endorsers Community here:

        http://www.linkedin.com/groups/Open-Endorsers-Skill-Endorsements-Open-4685008/about

        • Neal Schaffer
          Feb 02 - 12:15 pm

          I agree, Ed, that Endorsements could be used as part of some type of algorithm to “score” you. Either way, in my opinion, it’s not about feeling positive or negative about them but in learning how to best utilize them to help your achieve whatever objective you might have for being on LinkedIn.

          • Ed Brophy (@IncomeTrue)
            Feb 24 - 5:29 pm

            Linkedin Finally Giving SEO Weight to Skill Endorsements:

            I’m not quite sure how this works yet Neil, but Linkedin is beginning to give some SEO weight to skill endorsement keywords now, like you said they would.

            For example, I went to “people” on my Linkedin home page and typed in “System Testing.” David Carpin (open endorser) came up #3 on the first page of Linkedin’s people search for “System Testing,” yet those words are not listed anywhere else on his profile, except as a skill.

            I did the same for “property & casualty insurance”. Open endorser, “Mary (Wassink) Ganis” comes up #6. Property & Casualty Insurance” is listed as one of her skills, yet those keywords do not appear anywhere else on her profile.

            Also what I found interesting, is that listing skills that are not listed as Linkedin skills per se, are still found as well. This could be very helpful if something is a popular keyword at Google Adwords, but isn’t yet listed as a skill using Linkedin’s Skill & Expertise tool.

            I listed Dream Big Dreams as a skill and I beat every entrepreneur and self-made millionaire on Linkedin. Imagine that.

            Open Endorsers are Open Networkers…only they have more skills.

            Kind regards,
            Ed Brophy
            Open Endorser Group

          • Neal Schaffer
            Feb 24 - 7:56 pm

            VERY interesting Ed … I’m going to have to do my own experimenting, but I think you might be on to something here! Thanks for sharing!!!

          • Ed Brophy (@IncomeTrue)
            Mar 10 - 11:01 am

            Tech Crunch (3/6/2013) “Your profile is 4 times likely to get found if you get endorsed”:

            http://techcrunch.com/2013/03/06/endorsements-linkedins-answer-to-klout-passes-1b-recommendations-and-builds-up-a-new-data-set/

            Open Endorsers are Open Networkers-only they have more skills.

            Ed Brophy Open Endorsers’ Community:
            http://www.linkedin.com/groups/Skill-Endorsements-4685008

          • Neal Schaffer
            Mar 10 - 11:11 am

            Very interesting Ed – thanks for keeping me and all of our readers in the loop!

          • Ed Brophy (@IncomeTrue)
            Mar 14 - 12:25 pm

            Yes it is interesting isn’t it?

            It is interesting that this endorsement technology will forever evolve and be blind to most of us, yet human potential is what this personal branding and liking tool can really be about.

            It is interesting that the earning ability of Kim Kardashian’s is well over $65 million a year and some person with genuine talent or highly skilled may forever go unnoticed for the majority of their career.

            It is interesting that during the presidential polls millions and millions of trustworthy Americans walked into polling places all across the country and also endorsed local judges, councilman, and other county officials that these citizens never worked with; American citizens that endorsed the skills of thousands of local authorities that these millions of qualified voters knew little or nothing about.

            It is interesting that any wannabe lacking endorsements on Linkedin – any foreigner, new person just getting started, or some homely looking human could improve the perception viewers have of their profile by paying $50 million to Beyonce like Pepsi did – to increase social proof that the product of their skill is finally pretty worthy of endorsement..

            It is interesting that people on Linkedin still do not understand the principle of social proof or that truth is irrelevant and perception is everything – in the real world of personal branding and fueling a career.

            Ed Brophy, Open Endorsers’ Community:
            http://www.linkedin.com/groups/Skill-Endorsements-4685008

            Open Endorsers are Open Networkers – only they have more skills.

          • Neal Schaffer
            Mar 15 - 9:52 pm

            Ed – I must say that I’ve really enjoyed our conversations regarding LinkedIn Endorsements that have happened through the comments of this blog post! In fact, I will probably be taking the contents of what you have written about and repurpose it into a blog post – giving you full credit for the ideas that you have submitted – at some point in the future. We are in an always evolving world of social media, so at one point what seemed trivial can potentially have a huge impact in the future. LinkedIn Endorsements are no different. Thanks for opening up the eyes of not only myself but for all of my readers! And let’s keep the conversation going as this grand experiment evolves!

  8. Adam Helweh
    Jan 03 - 10:37 pm

    The best article I’ve read so far regarding endorsements. I completely agree with you. Spot on with each point. One thing I did hear from a recent post on Mashable was how an element of friction might curb any endorsements from folks fishing for their own or that have little familiarity with your actual experience in the displayed skilled. The friction would mean removing the automatic prompt that is profiled with skills suggestions at the top of profiles you visit. I agree that removing that would make endorsing a more intentional action and deture folks who are breezing by and clicking the first thing they see in the name of quantity over quality.

    • Neal Schaffer
      Jan 03 - 10:44 pm

      Thanks Adam! As for that Mashable post, which came out the same day as mine (today), that was an op-ed piece. LinkedIn is going to do what they are going to do, so rather than talk about how people might feel about it or how LinkedIn can improve it, I concentrate on how to maximize the here and now. Completely different perspective.

  9. Joel Don (@joeldon)
    Jan 04 - 7:01 am

    Very nice job Neal of stepping back, letting the dust settle and offering a variety ways to leverage the new Endorsements feature. Yes, there have been detractors to Endorsements. It does seem like LinkedIn’s version of a “poke.” I liken it to a way to simply say “howdy” in a single click. I’ve used it for that purpose. One technical question/point: in tracking the email alerts for Endorsements, it appears that you can endorse someone more than once for the same Skill. And you get an email alert every time. Do you see that? If true, does it tend to detract from the feature? It might *appear* the connection is randomly endorsing.

    • Neal Schaffer
      Jan 04 - 10:54 am

      Thanks Joel. To respond to your comment, what you’re seeing is the emergence of LinkedIn as a platform for engagement with other profiles. Similar to how if someone pokes or tags you too many times in Facebook and “spams” your notifications, I see the same thing emerging on LinkedIn with those who potentially abuse the Endorsements functionality. Time will tell…

  10. Amy Hall
    Jan 04 - 12:22 pm

    I didn’t really understand endorsements, and now I do. Thanks Neal!

  11. Dave Kearns (@DaveK0101)
    Jan 04 - 2:32 pm

    I had to reject an endorsement once. Due to how it read and a misspelled word. The linkedIN system asked me if I wanted to have the person revise it, so I did. and he did and I now use it. Last place I worked, most the engineers and other work associates, are on linkedIN because the big boss told them to find the time and make a profile. They had no real plan in place or anything. I’m still waiting for the person in charge of their Twitter account to follow me back. lol

  12. Dave Kearns (@DaveK0101)
    Jan 04 - 2:41 pm

    Oops! I forgot to add the answer to your question Neal! I plan to focus in on the endorsements I’ve received and see how they match up with the 4 key skills I like to shed light on within my resume. I figure if I left a lasting impression on people to go out of their way to say something kind and positive about my performance, then how can that not be a good thing? Then I’ll balance their comments with what I currently see as my strong suits and go from there. Just perhaps those are the skills I should bring to the forefront on my resume, at the very least, mention them.

    • Neal Schaffer
      Jan 04 - 5:34 pm

      Glad to hear that you plan to make good use of the knowledge Dave! Thanks for all of your social sharing and support!

  13. VideoLeadsOnline
    Jan 04 - 10:57 pm

    I endorse this article (he he).

  14. GoodPeopleJapan
    Jan 07 - 12:21 am

    Interesting Neal, thanks.

    I’d been wondering what to do about people Endorsing me for Skills I barely have, or worse that I know they have no idea whether they are my skills or not.

    When I had a chance to look at Edit Profile, I can see that I can show or not show ALL Endorsement, or on a Skill by Skill, Person by Person (Tick Box) basis. This is good, as I was accepting everything to start with & now want to go back and have a solid look at who is endorsing & for what.

    So pretty much that blows the complaints out of the water – the ability to control not only what you accept & who you endorse (I only endorse people for things I know they are strong & well known in), but also what you show to an exact Endorsement level (by Skill & person Endorsing).

    Stop complaining about the inane-ness of it, and work with what you have and have control over I say!

    As other commenters have said, what a wonderful opportunity for you to do it right, whatever you think of the service, an opportunity to reach out to people and have a real connection with them because of an endorsement (either way!).

    • Neal Schaffer
      Jan 07 - 11:10 am

      “Stop complaining about the inane-ness of it, and work with what you have and have control over I say!” – I couldn’t agree with you more Jason!!!

  15. Tom Powner
    Jan 07 - 7:27 am

    Great Article,
    I just wanted to add one note to think about. Know your company’s social media policy. Many companies today have a clear defined social media policy and in some cases taking part in giving or accepting any type of endorsements can be in violation of that policy.

  16. [...] 8 Ways to Make LinkedIn Endorsements Work for You and Your Network 0var dd_offset_from_content = 40; var dd_top_offset_from_content = 50; jQuery(document).ready(function($) { window.setTimeout('loadTwitter_3133()',1000);window.setTimeout('loadFBShare_3133()',1000);window.setTimeout('loadGoogle1_3133()',1000);window.setTimeout('loadLinkedin_3133()',1000); }); function loadTwitter_3133(){ jQuery(document).ready(function($) { $('.dd-twitter-3133').remove();$.getScript('http://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js&#039 ;) ; }); } function loadFBShare_3133(){ jQuery(document).ready(function($) { $('.dd-fbshare-3133').remove(); $.getScript('http://static.ak.fbcdn.net/connect.php/js/FB.Share&#039 ;) ; }); } function loadGoogle1_3133(){ jQuery(document).ready(function($) { $('.dd-google1-3133').remove();$.getScript('https://apis.google.com/js/plusone.js&#039 ;) ; }); } function loadLinkedin_3133(){ jQuery(document).ready(function($) { $('.dd-linkedin-3133').remove();$.getScript('http://platform.linkedin.com/in.js&#039 ;) ; }); }BioTwitterFacebookGoogle+LinkedIn FrithjofFrithjof is Jedi Master at Tweet4Ok he helps Businesses, Organizations and Individuals use Social Media Tools more effectively. He knows that we can use Social Media tools like Twitter, Facebook, YouTube, LinkedIn and the many others effectively for marketing but the real power of these tools is the ability to create powerful Social Networks. [...]

  17. Hank Cohen
    Jan 08 - 9:40 pm

    Well Neal as I wrote to you a few months back I think that endorsements as Linken-in has implemented them are a bad idea and your article has not changed my mind.

    It is important to compare this endorsement feature with the older recommendation feature. Recommendations were something that required that the person doing the recommending actually know something and be willing to put in some effort to write it down. As a result recommendations were usually thoughtful and helpful in understanding something about a person. Endorsements in contrast require no effort on the part of the endorser beyond a kind intention and a single mouse click. The kind intention is a good thing and a simple “like” a la Facebook, would be a reasonable vote of confidence. Unfortunately every day I get endorsements from kind hearted acquaintances for skills that they could not possibly know that I might or might not possess.

    As an example of the problem with endorsements I could add a skill such as biochemistry to my profile. Now I don’t really know a thing about biochemistry but I’d be willing to bet that I would be getting endorsements for that skill within a week. It happens when I go to Linked-in and it asks me if I want to endorse Fred McMurry for Fatherhood. (I’m showing my age) Who wouldn’t endorse Fred McMurry for Fatherhood, sure I’ll check the box. But the fact is that I don’t know anything at all about whether Fred McMurry was a good father or not. Who wants to endorse Joan Crawford for Motherhood?

    • Neal Schaffer
      Jan 09 - 1:01 pm

      Greetings Hank. I’m really not discussing the like or hate of the new feature, but the fact that it’s now part of the platform and professionals should learn to leverage the functionality. I hear ‘ya that it’s not perfect by any means – and I also prefer Recommendations MUCH MORE than Endorsements – so I look at it is an experiment in crowdsourcing everyone’s skills graph through their LinkedIn connections.

      • Hank Cohen
        Jan 13 - 11:15 am

        Neal,
        I seriously think that endorsements are a waste of time. They may be fun to accumulate but HR folks will not use them for screening and hiring managers will not consider them in evaluations so what’s the point? Far better for a Linked-in user to have a few well considered recommendations than a plethora of meaningless endorsement.

        As I see it these endorsements are a debased currency that will degrade the value of Linked-in long term. As such I just don’t see the point in trying to glean any benefit. I know, based on the endorsements that I receive, that they are essentially meaningless so I assume that everyone else will see the same thing. While linked-in users may think that they can benefit from being endorsed, hiring managers will discount and ignore them. Furthermore if it is true as you say that they are not available for screening searches they don’t even figure into the key business driver of Linked-in.
        Best regards,
        Hank

        • Neal Schaffer
          Jan 13 - 11:43 am

          Hank – if this were an Op Ed piece, I would agree with almost 100% of what you say, especially the fact that Recommendations should be seen as being much more important than any mere Endorsement will ever be … AND that most professionals I know do feel that Endorsements – with the additional “engaging” emails being sent from LinkedIn – HAVE devalued the user experience for many. I’ll stop there ;-)

  18. [...] 8 Ways to Make LinkedIn Endorsements Work for You and Your Network (windmillnetworking.com) [...]

  19. [...] a ‘Manage Endorsements’ feature and here’s an article from LinkedIn specialist Neal Schaffer: Make LinkedIn Endorsements Work for You and Your Network if you want to read about this in more [...]

  20. [...] 8 Ways to Make LinkedIn Endorsements Work for You and Your Network [...]

  21. [...] 8 Ways to Make LinkedIn Endorsements Work for You and Your Network [...]

  22. [...] 8 Ways to Make LinkedIn Endorsements Work for You and Your Network (Source: WindMill Networking) [...]

  23. [...] Examples of taps include liking somebody’s update or sharing that update with your network. LinkedIn’s Endorsement feature is another example of a tap. Taps are quick and easy (generally one click). However, every time you [...]

  24. [...] Endorse my prospect for a particular skill on LinkedIn (see 8 Ways to Make LinkedIn Endorsements Work for You and Your Network). [...]

Leave a Reply

Mobile Theme